{"id":"a875eaa83475d4d3","commit_hash":"55e1edcd506c9c2c6bcad013bad8855deaff20609201ec6d0e094826c8446bd1","recomputed_hash":"55e1edcd506c9c2c6bcad013bad8855deaff20609201ec6d0e094826c8446bd1","hash_valid":true,"anchor_status":"anchored","anchors":[{"calendar_url":"https://alice.btc.calendar.opentimestamps.org/digest","submitted_at":1785311787216,"status":"submitted","proof_bytes":172},{"calendar_url":"https://bob.btc.calendar.opentimestamps.org/digest","submitted_at":1785311788292,"status":"submitted","proof_bytes":205},{"calendar_url":"https://finney.calendar.eternitywall.com/digest","submitted_at":1785311788507,"status":"submitted","proof_bytes":121}],"commitment":{"base_rates_shown":{"moving_n":232,"n":319,"p_down":0.3184257602862254,"p_flat":0.29874776386404295,"p_up":0.3828264758497317,"prior_strength":240},"baselines":{"base_rate":{"p_down":0.3184257602862254,"p_flat":0.29874776386404295,"p_up":0.3828264758497317},"persistence":{"p_down":1,"p_flat":0,"p_up":0},"pool_z":{"p_down":0.4215256672710842,"p_flat":0.29551235223855665,"p_up":0.2829619804903591},"uniform":{"p_down":0.3333333333333333,"p_flat":0.3333333333333333,"p_up":0.3333333333333333}},"call_type":"directional","coinflip":{"drawn_vector":{"p_down":0,"p_flat":1,"p_up":0},"params":{"method":"sha256-byte0-mod3","space":["up","down","flat"]},"seed":"a41f2f08e97fc728"},"config_epoch":6,"config_fingerprint":"5b899d319868d60d7abd1c7d194beae045d0efd8a7e9656ceadc08b29fb141f9","conviction_edge":0.1912,"created_at":1785311688939,"debate_chart_id":"f0c6f93d6dcd041c","decision_completed_at":1785311765246,"decision_started_at":1785311746716,"entry_bar_day":"2026-07-28","entry_bar_timestamp":1785272400000,"entry_ingested_at":1785311589108,"entry_price_reconciled":{"delta":0,"mode":"close","second_source_id":"yahoo","second_value":57.29600143432617,"verdict":"ok"},"entry_reference_price":57.29600143432617,"event_flags":["fomc_blackout"],"evidence_cutoff_at":1785311688939,"feed_source_id":"yahoo","fetch_timestamps":{"entry_bar_ingested_at":1785311589108,"evidence_checked_at":1785311688939},"flat_band_pct":0.007775613075408069,"forecast":{"p_down":0.4480650911771113,"p_flat":0.30567573838618156,"p_up":0.24625917043670717},"grading_series":{"contract_id":"","pin":null,"series_note":"spot_bootstrap_futures_proxy","source":"yahoo"},"headline_direction":"down","horizon":"1d","horizon_sessions":1,"id":"a875eaa83475d4d3","indicator_pack_hash":"5cccbbda3d233af9f4d382f46b686e514529e395d9f23d021c8b730a07da332d","info_lag_minutes":655,"instrument":"silver","judge_meta":{"abstained_all_degraded":false,"agreement":0.837,"base_rate_shrink":0.2,"calibration_eff_n":0,"calibration_fitted":false,"calibration_n":0,"calibration_temperature":1,"extremization":1,"live_pools":3,"magnitude_source":"coherent_historical_mixture","missing_pools":0,"pre_calibration_vector":{"p_down":0.4480650911771113,"p_flat":0.30567573838618156,"p_up":0.24625917043670717},"unstable_pools":[],"weights":{"A":1,"B":1,"C":1}},"judge_version":"judge-2.0.0","k_flat":0.25,"ledger_written_at":1785311786127,"market_class":"metal","move_forecast":{"class_counts":{"down":98,"flat":87,"up":134},"distribution_version":"return-mixture-1.0.0","historical_sample_n":319,"implied_probabilities":{"p_down":0.4480650911771113,"p_flat":0.30567573838618156,"p_up":0.24625917043670717},"interval80_high":2.97,"interval80_low":-4.51,"point_pct":-0.76,"source":"coherent_historical_mixture","synthetic_support":[]},"news_seed_ids":["a57bdc2749771cce","314f2dd61b5b2f7c","3be435cb33967e41","bbc870cb2ecccee1"],"panel":[{"adjustment_reasons":["Silver has dropped 2.011% today, approaching the lower end of its typical daily move of 3.11%."],"base_rate_anchor":"Silver has a 38% chance of up, 32% chance of down, and 30% chance of flat over the next day.","confidence":0.4,"degraded":false,"horizon_view":"1d","key_point":"Silver will test below 57.20 if the Fed meeting triggers a selloff, given light positioning and a strong dollar.","knowledge_entry_ids":["8917af2eecb1fb2b","964d49a7c6c06a3d","200dc086fd12214b"],"lean":"down","model_version":"openrouter:mistralai/mistral-small-3.2-24b-instruct","persona_id":"metals_expert","persona_version":"1.0.0","seat_cause":"desk_balance","silent_reason":null,"stance":"flat","stance_vector":null},{"adjustment_reasons":["The market is pricing in caution ahead of the Federal Reserve meeting, indicated by news reports, leading to selling pressure on precious metals.","The US dollar basket has firmed to 94.795, which typically weighs on dollar-denominated commodities like silver.","Elevated 10-year Treasury yields at 4.65% per annum reduce the appeal of non-yielding assets like silver.","Today's 2.011% decline is already outside the historical flat band of ±0.78%, indicating a strong directional move."],"base_rate_anchor":"Historically, Silver moves up 38% of the time, down 32% of the time, and remains flat 30% of the time over a single day, based on 319 observations with a flat band of ±0.78%.","confidence":0.7,"degraded":false,"horizon_view":"1d","key_point":"Silver will likely continue its downward trend if the US dollar basket remains firm above 94.795 and the market's anticipation of the Fed meeting continues to pressure precious metals.","knowledge_entry_ids":["2cc71a8b802d7f8f","73461284ad44da36","936ebe394eb2f24a"],"lean":"down","model_version":"openrouter:google/gemini-2.5-flash","persona_id":"cb_watcher","persona_version":"1.0.0","seat_cause":"desk_balance","silent_reason":null,"stance":"down","stance_vector":null},{"adjustment_reasons":["The price has just fallen 2.011%, which is a larger-than-usual move against a typical daily move of 3.11%.","The market is positioned for a Fed meeting, with clear news flow likely to drive direction, reducing the chance of a flat, sideways session."],"base_rate_anchor":"For a single session, the base rates are 38% up, 32% down, and 30% flat (with a flat band of ±0.78%).","confidence":0.5,"degraded":false,"horizon_view":"1d","key_point":"The market is overpricing Fed hawkishness for the next session; silver will hold above $56.73 if the Fed statement does not contain a materially new tightening signal, showing my down stance is wrong.","knowledge_entry_ids":["626abe5e4f2da52b","d6e25c3170124fe5"],"lean":"down","model_version":"openrouter:deepseek/deepseek-chat-v3.1","persona_id":"geo_risk_hawk","persona_version":"1.0.0","seat_cause":"desk_balance","silent_reason":null,"stance":"down","stance_vector":null},{"adjustment_reasons":[],"base_rate_anchor":"","confidence":0,"degraded":true,"horizon_view":"1d","key_point":"","knowledge_entry_ids":["3f65a156acb287fa","6723dded6821d7fc","75546711d084f621","861202f498aae046"],"lean":"up","model_version":null,"persona_id":"risk_manager","persona_version":"1.0.0","seat_cause":"desk_balance","silent_reason":null,"stance":"flat","stance_vector":null},{"adjustment_reasons":["Price declined by 2.011% today, a move larger than the typical 3.11% daily range.","The bearish Tenkan-Kijun cross below the cloud supports further downside pressure.","Price remains below the cloud, indicating bearish equilibrium.","Market news shows pressure from a stronger dollar and rate-hike fears, reinforcing potential weakness."],"base_rate_anchor":"Historically, silver moves up 38%, down 32%, or stays flat 30% over one day within a ±0.78% no-change band.","confidence":0.6,"degraded":false,"horizon_view":"1d","key_point":"If silver closes below the Tenkan line near 57.517, it would confirm continued weakness and likely further downside in the next session.","knowledge_entry_ids":["090a938ec7a1d794","4ceeffa032dfdb0f","79a56ab66a8595b3","b1541ba7661ed3ff"],"lean":"down","model_version":"openrouter:openai/gpt-4.1-mini","persona_id":"ichimoku","persona_version":"1.0.0","seat_cause":"topical","silent_reason":null,"stance":"down","stance_vector":null},{"adjustment_reasons":["The market has fallen -2.011% on the day, showing immediate downward momentum.","The dollar is strengthening and real yields are high, creating a strong, synchronous headwind.","The price is -0.81 ATRs below its 20-day average, confirming bearish short-term positioning."],"base_rate_anchor":"The 1-day base rates show silver rises 38% of the time, falls 32%, and is flat 30% (within ±0.78%).","confidence":0.7,"degraded":false,"horizon_view":"1d","key_point":"Silver will struggle to reclaim the 57.296 session close if the dollar basket remains above 94.718 and the 10-year real yield holds above 2.43%.","knowledge_entry_ids":["1ec5072d59858d87","48c543b48802c6b2","de1ff57142ccbfb8","edfbb5c6aaa20a67"],"lean":"down","model_version":"openrouter:deepseek/deepseek-chat-v3.1","persona_id":"breadth_intermarket","persona_version":"1.0.0","seat_cause":"topical","silent_reason":null,"stance":"down","stance_vector":null},{"adjustment_reasons":["Price is substantially below the 50-day average by 4.53 ATRs, signaling a clear downtrend pressure.","Recent 2.01% daily decline is within the typical daily move of 3.11%, showing continuation of recent selling.","MACD histogram is shrinking but remains negative, suggesting bearish momentum may be fading but not reversing."],"base_rate_anchor":"Historically, the 1-day move is up 38%, down 32%, and flat 30%.","confidence":0.6,"degraded":false,"horizon_view":"1d","key_point":"If price closes below the 50-day average at 65.3751 minus 4.53 ATRs (approximately 57.3), it confirms ongoing downtrend pressure for the next session.","knowledge_entry_ids":["0411083ec9cdb5a1","34180e7fe259c8da","451e537572802289","d0d5641dce473933"],"lean":"down","model_version":"openrouter:openai/gpt-4.1-mini","persona_id":"trend_ma","persona_version":"1.0.0","seat_cause":"topical","silent_reason":null,"stance":"down","stance_vector":null},{"adjustment_reasons":["silver closed down 2.011% at 57.296, near the bottom of its 60-day range at the 0.067 position and 17.85% below its 200-day average.","news flow shows spot silver falling nearly 3% to 56.73 amid a market selloff and caution before the Fed meeting.","real rates well above neutral do compounding damage; the longer policy stays tight after inflation turns, the harder the landing it buys."],"base_rate_anchor":"1-day base rates are up 38% / down 32% / flat 30% (n=319, flat band ±0.78%).","confidence":0.6,"degraded":false,"horizon_view":"1d","key_point":"A 10-year real yield holding above 2.4% combined with the US dollar basket above 94.7 would drive silver lower; this would be falsified by a close back above 58.47.","knowledge_entry_ids":["4c666b20659dd215","d6ddf5b7ee982f1d","f3288e90ef0515a0"],"lean":"down","model_version":"openrouter:x-ai/grok-4.20","persona_id":"macro_dove","persona_version":"1.0.0","seat_cause":"topical","silent_reason":null,"stance":"down","stance_vector":null},{"degraded":false,"knowledge_entry_ids":[],"model_version":null,"persona_id":"volume_flow","persona_version":"1.0.0","seat_cause":null,"silent_reason":"the volume and money-flow measures he reads were too close to neutral to argue either way","stance":"silent"},{"degraded":false,"knowledge_entry_ids":[],"model_version":null,"persona_id":"candlestick","persona_version":"1.0.0","seat_cause":null,"silent_reason":"the candle patterns he reads were too close to neutral to argue either way","stance":"silent"},{"degraded":false,"knowledge_entry_ids":[],"model_version":null,"persona_id":"volume_profile","persona_version":"1.0.0","seat_cause":null,"silent_reason":"the value-area measures he reads were too close to neutral to argue either way","stance":"silent"}],"pool_votes":[{"best_argument":"All 7 analysts lean down with moderate to high confidence, supported by strong dollar and 10-year real yield levels above key thresholds, indicating likely downside pressure on silver.","degraded":false,"model_version":"openrouter:openai/gpt-4.1-mini","pool_id":"A","vector":{"p_down":0.55,"p_flat":0.35,"p_up":0.10000000000000002}},{"best_argument":"Silver shows strong bearish momentum with price trading below all major moving averages, down 17.85% from its 200-day SMA, and forming a doji candle after a -2.01% gap down, indicating continuation weakness.","degraded":false,"model_version":"openrouter:deepseek/deepseek-chat-v3.1","pool_id":"B","vector":{"p_down":0.4049963095386918,"p_flat":0.2500167759157652,"p_up":0.344986914545543}},{"best_argument":"Silver prices have already declined significantly, with market news indicating a drop of nearly 3% and a general selloff ahead of the Federal Reserve meeting, suggesting continued downward pressure.","degraded":false,"model_version":"openrouter:google/gemini-2.5-flash","pool_id":"C","vector":{"p_down":0.45000000000000007,"p_flat":0.3,"p_up":0.25000000000000006}}],"pool_z_version":"poolz-1.0.0","regime_label_pit":"trend_midvol","resolution_day":"2026-07-29","run_id":"run-2026-07-29-31c1e05442fdd6ce","salience_inputs":null,"second_source_id":"yahoo","spans_weekend":false,"strength":"strong","strong_call":true,"topic_source":"pinned","trade_day":"2026-07-29"},"resolution":null,"how_to_verify":"sha256 over the canonical serialization (sorted keys) of `commitment` must equal commit_hash; anchors hold OpenTimestamps calendar proofs of that digest."}